The Power of Amazon Top Reviewers: Boosting Sales and Credibility

On This Post

Consumer reviews are one of the most trusted resources for making purchase decisions today. Studies show that over 90% of shoppers read reviews before buying a product online. When it comes to Amazon – the largest ecommerce marketplace – product ratings and reviews are even more influential in customers’ decision making process. This makes garnering positive reviews on Amazon a crucial part of establishing credibility and driving sales. But not all Amazon reviews hold equal weight. This is where Amazon Top Reviewers come into play.

Amazon Top Reviewers are an elite group of reviewers who have earned a badge on the platform for their consistently high-quality, detailed contributions. Their reviews are prominently displayed and likely to be some of the most read by prospective buyers. Securing reviews from these influential reviewers can take a brand’s success on Amazon to the next level.

Defining Amazon Top Reviewers: An Elite Group of Influencers

So what qualifies a reviewer for Amazon’s coveted Top Reviewer badge? The specific criteria is not publicly disclosed, but observing patterns of these reviewers provides insight into how Amazon makes the distinction:
  • Prolific reviewers who have written a high volume of reviews on their account. The number required seems to be at least 50-100.
  • Maintaining a very high percentage of reviews rated as helpful. Typically over 80-90% of their reviews need to receive votes from other customers highlighting their usefulness.
  • Consistent, high-quality contributions that provide meaningful details and insights in the reviews, rather than just a few generic sentences.
  • Active participation in the reviewer community, like responding to comments on their reviews and engaging in discussion forums.
  • Reviews across a breadth of different products/categories, not just focused on one type of item.
Essentially, Amazon looks for seasoned reviewers who take their roles seriously, provide thoughtful perspectives, and participate actively in the community. In return for this high bar, Top Reviewer status grants privilege and influence. Some of the key benefits include:
  • A “Top Reviewer” badge displayed prominently on their profile, so other customers immediately recognize their authority.
  • Priority placement in product reviews, so their feedback is much more visible.
  • Early access to new products that brands submit to Amazon Vine, a program offering free products to trusted reviewers.
  • Weight in Amazon’s algorithms, so Top Reviewer ratings and reviews can bump products up in search and product listings.
  • Recognition as some of the most helpful voices on Amazon’s crowded platform.
Top Reviewer status is not easy to obtain, but those who earn it become trusted voices whose opinions can make or break products. For shoppers on the fence, insights from a Top Reviewer they recognize can give them the confidence to click Buy Now.

The Powerful Impact of Reviews on Buying Decisions

Plenty of research underscores how significantly reviews influence purchasing behavior, especially in the digital space. According to a BrightLocal consumer survey:
  • Over half of consumers will not buy from a business that has an average rating lower than 4 stars.
  • 88% trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations.
  • Over 70% of people say positive reviews make them trust a business more.
When it comes to Amazon specifically, reviews are even more crucial in the customer’s decision journey. Because buyers can’t see or test products in person before purchasing, they rely heavily on ratings and reviews for information. Key statistics:
  • 82% of Amazon shoppers reference reviews before adding an item to their cart.
  • Products with more than 50 reviews sell up to 150% more than those with no reviews.
  • Buyers need an average of 4.3 stars to consider buying electronics. Household products need 4.0 stars.
Reviews help consumers vet products, feel confident about purchases, and choose between alternatives. But not all Amazon reviews hold equal influence. This is where securing reviews from elite Amazon Top Reviewers becomes critical.

How Top Reviewers Reviews Differ from Standard Ones

While all Amazon reviews can impact potential customers, reviews from Top Reviewers are substantially more visible and trusted. Standard reviews from verified purchasers carry some weight. But Top Reviewer reviews bring much greater authority. Here’s why:
  • Prominent placement under the product details, so they’re more likely to be read
  • Badge signaling the reviewer’s status as an authority figure
  • History of detailed, helpful reviews lends credibility
  • Perception that Amazon has vetted and approved them as a valuable voice
  • Tendency to be more in-depth and analytical compared to many standard reviews
  • Reviews come from experienced, knowledgeable veterans of the platform
For all of these reasons, potential buyers place far greater trust in Top Reviewer perspectives. One detail-rich, thoughtful review from a Top Reviewer can often outweigh a dozen or more standard reviews.
Consider this example…
A new kitchen gadget has an average 4.2 star rating over 215 reviews. However, the most upvoted review with 1,723 votes comes from a Top Reviewer detailing some design flaws and performance issues they noticed when testing it extensively.
Many customers would likely hesitate to purchase upon seeing this review, even with generally positive ratings otherwise. The Top Reviewer’s input carries that much influence – enough to possibly tank sales. That’s just one example of how crucial securing positive Top Reviewer feedback is.

Why You Should Make Amazon Top Reviewers a Priority

For ecommerce brands selling on Amazon, focusing efforts specifically on getting reviews from Top Reviewers yields many benefits:

Increased Sales Positive ratings and reviews directly translate to higher conversion rates and more sales. Products with Top Reviewer endorsements are more likely to get added to carts.

Improved Visibility Favorable reviews, especially from recognized Top Reviewers, bump items upward in search rankings and product listings. More visibility means more potential buyers.

Reduced Buyer Skepticism Many shoppers are wary of fake reviews. But seeing validation from authoritative Top Reviewers eases those concerns and builds credibility.

Expanded Reach Reviews often influence search algorithms and related item recommendations. Positive Top Reviewer reviews help put products in front of more buyers.

The compounding impact of collecting feedback from the most listened-to voices on Amazon is clear. While all reviews matter for SEO and social proof, Top Reviewer testimonials provide the biggest boost to sales, visibility, and buyer confidence. But how can sellers effectively reach and request reviews from this elite group?

5 Strategies to Find and Connect with Amazon's Top Reviewers

Securing reviews from Top Reviewers takes effort beyond mass email blasts. You’ll need to identify and build relationships with reviewers who cover categories relevant to your products. Here are 5 proven tactics to help find and initiate contact with Amazon’s most influential users:
  1. Peruse Amazon’s Top Reviewer Spotlights One starting point is browsing the Top Reviewer profiles that Amazon chooses to spotlight publicly. Visit Amazon’s Top Reviewer section and look for reviewers in sections related to your products. Compile a list of prospects to potentially reach out to.
  2. Use Reviewer Analysis Tools Tools like ReviewKick, AmzDiscover, and Top Reviewer can help analyze reviewer data to identify frequent contributors. Look at their review history and helpful votes to vet usefulness. Compile a list of 5-10 strong matches.
  3. Participate in Amazon’s Seller Discussion Forums The Amazon Seller Central forums often have product reviewers participating in discussions. Jump into relevant conversations and build connections by providing value. Don’t overtly self-promote.
  4. Join Industry-Specific Facebook Groups Groups like the Amazon Sellers Club contain members who review products. Become an active participant in discussions and build rapport over time.
  5. Acquire an Email List Paid services like Top Reviewer offer email lists of top reviewers open to contact about reviews. Ensure you have permission before emailing any reviewers.
Take time to carefully identify and vet potential Top Reviewers rather than blasting every address available. Prioritize reviewers who will align with your product niche and brand. Now let’s explore how to effectively and politely request reviews once you’ve compiled your prospect list.

9 Recommendations for Successfully Requesting Top Amazon Reviews

Reaching out directly to request reviews from Top Reviewers requires tact and care. Avoid coming across as spammy or entitled. Instead, politely make your case for why their feedback would be valued by both your brand and the wider community. Here are some best practices:
  1. Personalize Outreach Emails Send individual emails explaining who you are, what your company provides, and why the reviewer’s input would be appreciated. Avoid mass template blasts.
  2. Send Products to Review via FBA Leverage Fulfilled By Amazon to directly send products to prospects. Include a personalized note with your package.
  3. Enable Amazon Review Collection Emails Turn on automated emails through your Seller Central asking recent purchasers for reviews. This adds helpful social proof.
  4. Follow Up Once One appropriate, polite follow-up is acceptable if you get no initial response. Then move on – constantly badgering reviewers will damage your brand.
  5. Integrate Review Inserts Include professional print inserts in your packaging requesting reviews if customers are satisfied. Keep messaging classy.
  6. Survey Customers Send post-purchase surveys asking about their experience. This primes them to leave reviews later.
  7. Provide Exceptional Service Satisfied customers are much more likely to review. Invest in prompt communication and issue resolution.
  8. Share Discount Codes Offer discounts like 20% off their next purchase in exchange for an open and honest review. But don’t require a positive review.
  9. Maintain Integrity Never pay for reviews. Focus on building authentic relationships, not questionable shortcuts that can backfire.
The key is politely explaining why a Top Reviewer’s voice can uniquely help other buyers, while respecting their time and feedback. These strategies help prompt reviews while avoiding aggressive or overly-promotional tactics.

Now let’s explore additional options for showcasing positive ratings once you begin collecting reviews. This will maximize their visibility and impact.

How to Highlight Ratings & Reviews for Increased Influence

A stellar Top Reviewer testimonial can bolster your product credibility and conversions. But consumers are more likely to notice and trust large volumes of reviews. That’s why acquiring a critical mass of reviews is still important.

Once you start garnering customer feedback, take steps to amplify the impact through smart presentation. Useful tactics include:

  • Display key excerpts from Top Reviewer testimonials on your product pages, mailers, and social media. Quote their feedback or link to the full review.
  • Use informational product insert cards to showcase impressive stats like your average rating or total review count.
  • Enable Amazon badges to flaunt ratings in search results. The more real estate your ratings occupy, the more visible social proof.
  • Prominently showcase ratings, awards, and review excerpts on your website and other brand assets.
  • Consider video testimonials to put a human face to positive reviewers.
  • Leverage paid advertising options to highlight ratings on Amazon and other channels.
  • Strategically position products with high review volume in on-site and off-site promotional areas.
  • Share new reviews on social media to highlight momentum and social proof. Tag reviewers to expand reach.
Take every opportunity to showcase the collective impact of your ratings rather than just cherry-picking individual reviews. The overall sentiment carries more weight than any one voice.

Best Practices When Seeking Product Reviews

While reviews are crucial, some questionable tactics used to generate them often backfire. To maintain brand integrity, keep these guidelines in mind:
  • Never pay for reviews, offer excessive discounts conditional on positive reviews, or penalize negative reviews. This violates Amazon’s terms.
  • Avoid pressuring reviewers to remove or alter negative reviews. Address their feedback constructively instead.
  • Focus on developing genuine relationships and delivering standout customer service rather than spamming reviewers.
    Be conservative with review requests to recent customers. Don’t risk coming across as thirsty or desperate.
  • If contacting reviewers directly, ensure you have specific permission and keep messages personalized.
  • Have realistic expectations when sending products to reviewers. They may choose not to review or say what you want to hear. Respect their independence.
  • Stay engaged with reviewers you connect with rather than treating them as one-off transactions.
  • Monitor your accounts and listings closely for any signs of fraudulent reviews. Report immediately.
While the rewards of reviews are undeniable, long-term success comes from authenticity. Sustainable review-building stems from amazing products and customer experiences, not shady schemes.

The Bottom Line

In Amazon’s crowded marketplace, reviews make a massive impact on product discoverability, trust, and sales. But not all Amazon reviews hold equal influence with buyers. Cultivating reviews from elite Top Reviewers is one of the most high-impact ways to drive conversions and establish credibility.
This guide has explored proven methods for identifying these authoritative voices, reaching out politely, integrating compelling testimonials across platforms, and surfacing your collective ratings in creative ways. While obtaining Top Reviewer endorsements requires effort, their visible validation pays dividends.
Remember, genuine value, not gimmicks, ultimately wins with reviewers and buyers alike. So focus on delighting customers rather than chasing vanity metrics alone. With an outstanding product and smart review-building strategy, you can leverage Amazon’s Top Reviewers to propel your brand to lasting success. The sales, trust, and visibility gains are well worth the diligence to court these influential voices.

Frequently Asked Questions?

What is the significance of Amazon Top Reviewers?

Amazon Top Reviewers are a select group of reviewers on the platform who have consistently written high-quality, detailed reviews. Their reviews hold more influence and can significantly impact buyers’ decisions.

How are Amazon Top Reviewers identified and recognized?

While Amazon doesn’t publicly disclose specific criteria, patterns suggest that prolific reviewers with a high volume of helpful reviews, active participation in the reviewer community, and engagement across various product categories qualify for the Top Reviewer badge.

What benefits do Amazon Top Reviewers receive?

Top Reviewers enjoy privileges like a badge on their profile, priority placement for their reviews, early access to new products, and increased visibility in Amazon’s algorithms, which can boost their reviews and ratings’ impact.

How do reviews influence purchasing decisions on Amazon?

Reviews play a vital role in purchasing decisions on Amazon. Studies show that over 90% of shoppers read reviews before buying a product online. Positive reviews build credibility and trust, especially when buyers can’t physically examine products.

How do Amazon Top Reviewers' reviews differ from standard ones?

Reviews from Amazon Top Reviewers are more trusted and influential due to their placement, authority badge, history of detailed reviews, and active participation in the community. Their insights carry more weight compared to standard reviews.

Why should businesses prioritize getting reviews from Amazon Top Reviewers?

Positive reviews from Top Reviewers can lead to increased sales, improved visibility in search results, reduced buyer skepticism, and expanded reach. Their reviews carry more weight and influence potential buyers’ decisions.

How can sellers connect with Amazon's Top Reviewers?

Sellers can use strategies like perusingAmazon’s Top Reviewer Spotlights, utilizing reviewer analysis tools, participating in Amazon’s Seller Discussion Forums, joining industry-specific Facebook groups, and acquiring email lists to find and engage with Top Reviewers.

What are the recommended approaches for requesting reviews from Amazon Top Reviewers?

When reaching out to Top Reviewers, sellers should personalize outreach emails, use Fulfilled By Amazon to send products, enable Amazon’s review collection emails, follow up politely, integrate review inserts, survey customers, provide exceptional service, offer discount codes without requiring positive reviews, and maintain integrity.

How can businesses highlight ratings and reviews effectively?

Businesses can showcase Top Reviewer testimonials on product pages and social media, use product insert cards to display ratings and review counts, utilize Amazon badges to flaunt ratings in search results, and strategically position products with high review volumes.

What are the best practices for seeking product reviews without compromising integrity?

To maintain brand integrity, businesses should avoid paying for reviews, pressuring reviewers to alter negative feedback, spamming reviewers, or engaging in questionable tactics. Building genuine relationships, focusing on exceptional products and customer experiences, and respecting reviewers’ independence are key.


About The Author

Want to Promote Your Business on Our Lists?

Submit a request now to our review team and we will get back to you with details. You can also help add to these lists by becoming a contributor and joining the Crowdcreate expert network.

Follow Us On Social

Want to Grow your Business?
Ready to take your next step? Schedule a call with our experts today and discover how we can help you achieve your goals.

A Full Service Strategic Advisory & Marketing Agency